But Judge Cheryl Matthews has not yet decided whether Jennifer and James Crumbley should get new trials as a result. Matthews heard arguments from an appellate lawyer for James Crumbley, more than two ...

Crumbley, the mother of the Oxford High School shooter, asked in early March for Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Cheryl Matthews to disqualify Prosecutor Karen McDonald from her case because ...

Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Cheryl Matthews heard arguments on Jennifer's motion Jan. 31, and Friday heard arguments about James' motion. James Crumbley argued that prosecutors failed to ...

In her eight-page order issued Tuesday, Oakland County Circuit Judge Cheryl Matthews wrote that she "clearly does not have jurisdiction" to decide whether McDonald should be disqualified from the ...

He is the father of Oxford High School shooter Ethan Crumbley. Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Cheryl Matthews listened to arguments Friday inside a courtroom. The arguments centered on ...

Oakland County Circuit Judge Cheryl Matthews had previously held that the shooter's medical records were confidential, and that it was only the shooter who could decide whether to share them or not.

But Judge Cheryl Matthews has not yet decided whether Jennifer and James Crumbley should get new trials as a result. Advertisement Article continues below this ad Matthews heard arguments from an ...