Uncrustables' 'Fire' New Flavor Sounds Like 'Heaven in a Sandwich' first appeared on Parade on Jul 14, 2025 This story was originally reported by Parade on Jul 14, 2025, where it first appeared.

The Uncrustables gave the flavor profile of a sandwich you would bring to school lunch, even homemade. The Jams sandwich was loaded with peanut butter, which isn’t a bad thing of course, but the ...

Related: Nostalgic New Soda Flavor Fans Have 'Been Impatiently Waiting' for Is Finally Heading to Stores uncrustables-unveils-fire-new-limited-edition-flavor-that-fans-are-calling-heaven-in-a-sandwich ...

The Uncrustables gave the flavor profile of a sandwich you would bring to school lunch, even homemade. The Jams sandwich was loaded with peanut butter, which isn’t a bad thing of course, but the ...

Uncrustables win on classic strawberry flavor, but Jams' berry version makes it worth the buy. Though a bit pricier and slower to thaw, Jams offer a more filling, protein-rich twist on the ...

I highly recommend the berry flavor over the strawberry, but if you’re in a strawberry mood, I suggest stocking up on some Uncrustables, too—y’know, for balance.