Buffy Supima Cotton Sheet Set ($128, originally $150) "I'm not the best sleeper. I never have been, but I'm not going to go as far as saying I never will be because I'm holding out hope that'll ...

Fenton recommends the solid hemstitched Supima percale sheet set ($59-$69 for a pair of pillowcases; $59-$99 each for top and fitted sheets, garnethill.com).

Lands’ End’s 400-thread-count Supima cotton-sateen sheets are on sale for up to 50 percent off, depending on the color. They’re not as shiny as regular sateen sheets and feel soft and luxurious.

J by Jasper Conran Supima Cotton Fitted Sheet ... Boasting a modest but still winter appropriate 500 thread count, the Supima cotton fitter bed sheet has an elegant drape and a silky smooth feel.