University of Georgia alum Fred Baker III finally got his class ring back after over 50 years, but he tells PEOPLE that unfortunately, he's already lost it again.

Morgan Perigo was parted from his 1965 class ring from Canada’s McMaster University in 1977, when he was on vacation with his family in Barbados, according to CNN.

Bernard F. Sacra [center] is reunited with his long-lost Orange County High School class ring from 1961. Deputy Trey Carter [right] played a vital role in making that happen.