Right as she graduated from Grandview Heights High School in 1975, Melfi exchanged class rings with her then-boyfriend and drove to visit his brother in Golden Beach, Maryland, that May.

That's when he found a high school class ring dated to 1987. It was the second such ring he'd found and like the first, he was keen to reunite it with its owner.

Right as she graduated from Grandview Heights High School in 1975, Melfi exchanged class rings with her then-boyfriend and drove to visit his brother in Golden Beach, Maryland, that May.