By Lovia Gyarkye Arts & Culture Critic Fear Street’s conceit always felt ... and McCabe Slye (who played Tommy Slater in Part 2) as Mad Thomas, the town’s fanatical self-proclaimed prophet ...

a mad axeman and a Gothic enchantress (“Normal bitches don’t bleed black blood”) raise merry hell. But what Fear Street Part 1: 1994 gets right is that, played by a mostly unknown cast ...