Hands down, the No. 1 popsicle pick among our experts was Outshine. "It’s the brand I reach for most often because it’s easy to find, consistent, and made with fruit you can taste," Johnson says.

It all began June 16, when writer Eli McCann posted a TikTok about watermelon popsicles by GoodPop®, a frozen desserts brand in Texas. Eli liked the popsicles.